The Microbial Metallomics Theory of Endometriosis

Abstract

Endometriosis is a complex gynecological disorder characterized by the ectopic growth of endometrial tissue outside the uterine cavity. While existing theories focus on retrograde menstruation, immune dysfunction, and endocrine abnormalities, emerging evidence suggests a critical role for environmental toxicants, particularly heavy metals, in disease pathogenesis. Here, we propose the Microbial Metallomics Theory of Endometriosis, which integrates microbial metal metabolism, metalloestrogens, and host immune responses as key drivers of disease progression. We hypothesize that metals such as nickel (Ni), cadmium (Cd), lead (Pb), mercury (Hg), and arsenic (As) disrupt endometrial homeostasis through their interactions with microbial metallophores, metallothioneins, and metal-driven immune modulation. This framework introduces the concept that dysbiotic microbes leverage metallophores for metal acquisition, influencing immune evasion, oxidative stress, and estrogen metabolism in endometriotic lesions. Understanding this dynamic interplay between microbiome metal adaptations and host pathophysiology could lead to novel microbiome-targeted and metal chelation-based interventions for endometriosis management.

Keywords: Endometriosis, microbial metallomics, metalloestrogens, heavy metals, microbiome, immune dysfunction, oxidative stress, nickel allergy

Introduction

Endometriosis affects approximately 10-15% of reproductive-age women and is a leading cause of infertility and chronic pelvic pain. ^[1] Despite its prevalence, the precise etiology remains unresolved. Existing hypotheses implicate retrograde menstruation, genetic predisposition, hormonal imbalances, immune dysfunction, and environmental factors in disease development.

Among environmental risk factors, heavy metals and metalloestrogens have garnered increasing attention due to their ability to disrupt endocrine signaling, modulate immune responses, and induce oxidative stress.^[2] However, a critical but overlooked dimension is the role of microbial metallomics—the study of metal-microbe interactions in shaping biological processes. Given the emerging evidence that dysbiosis plays a causative role in endometriosis,^[3] understanding how microbes metabolize, sequester, and respond to metal exposure could reveal novel disease mechanisms.

This paper introduces the Microbial Metallomics Theory of Endometriosis, which posits that endometriosis is driven by a triangular interplay between heavy metal exposure, microbial metallophores, and host immune-metabolic responses. This theory builds upon research on metalloestrogens, microbial metal resistance mechanisms, and immune dysregulation, synthesizing them into a unified framework that offers new insights into the pathogenesis of endometriosis.

The Microbial Metallomics Theory of Endometriosis

Endometriosis is a multifaceted condition influenced by a complex interplay of environmental, microbial, and immunological factors. The Microbial Metallomics Theory of Endometriosis provides a unifying framework that connects metal exposure, microbiome dysbiosis, and immune dysfunction as primary drivers of disease progression. This theory proposes that toxic metals disrupt host-microbe interactions, modulating estrogen metabolism, immune evasion, and inflammatory responses, thereby fostering a microenvironment conducive to endometriotic lesion persistence. The mechanisms outlined below describe how microbial metallomics contributes to the pathophysiology of endometriosis through metal-induced hormonal disruptions, microbial virulence strategies, immune modulation, and epigenetic alterations. The proposed theory centers around five interconnected mechanisms:

2.1 Metalloestrogenic Activation and Hormonal Disruption

Heavy metals such as Ni, Cd, Pb, Hg, and As exhibit estrogen-mimicking properties, disrupting normal hormonal regulation and contributing to excessive endometrial proliferation and lesion persistence. Ni exposure, in particular, has been linked to menstrual cycle disorders, dysmenorrhea, and chronic inflammation, supporting its role in endometriosis.

2.2 Microbial Metallophores and Metal-Driven Pathogenicity

Dysbiotic bacteria in endometriosis, such as Proteobacteria and Staphylococcus spp., produce metallophores—small molecules that bind and transport metals—to outcompete commensal microbes. These metallophores facilitate metal sequestration, altering host immune responses and promoting bacterial virulence, which may contribute to chronic inflammation in endometriotic lesions.

2.3 Metallothioneins and Host-Microbe Conflicts Over Metal Homeostasis

Metallothioneins are metal-binding proteins that regulate metal detoxification, oxidative stress, and immune responses. Host metallothioneins attempt to sequester toxic metals, but microbial metallothioneins may counteract these efforts, leading to increased microbial survival and exacerbation of inflammation.

2.4 Nickel Sensitization and Immune Dysregulation

Studies have linked nickel allergy and immune dysfunction to endometriosis severity. Nickel’s ability to alter antigen presentation, disrupt T-cell responses, and increase inflammatory cytokines may explain why some women experience worsening endometriosis symptoms upon nickel exposure.

2.5 Epigenetic Reprogramming by Metal-Microbiome Interactions

Chronic exposure to toxic metals induces DNA methylation changes, histone modifications, and non-coding RNA alterations, leading to immune dysfunction and estrogen hypersensitivity in endometrial tissues. Certain microbes may modulate these epigenetic responses, either exacerbating or protecting against disease progression.

Addressing Gaps in Existing Theories

The Microbial Metallomics Theory of Endometriosis can address gaps in existing theories by providing a unifying mechanism that links environmental, microbial, and immunological factors to endometriosis pathogenesis. Below is an analysis of how microbial metallomics could support or enhance existing theories: 

Retrograde Menstruation Theory While retrograde menstruation is a widely accepted mechanism, it fails to explain why only a subset of individuals develop endometriosis. Microbial metallomics can provide insight into this disparity by suggesting that dysbiotic microbes colonizing the endometrial lining may use metallophores to modulate immune responses, allowing ectopic lesions to evade clearance. Additionally, metalloestrogens may drive the persistence of lesions by promoting chronic inflammation and estrogenic signaling in endometrial tissue. This theory also provides an alternative explanation for cases occurring in prepubertal girls, postmenopausal women, and even men, where environmental metal exposure and microbial adaptations could lead to non-hormonally driven lesion development. 

Environmental Theory The environmental theory suggests that exposure to toxins plays a role in endometriosis but struggles to establish direct causality. Microbial metallomics can bridge this gap by linking environmental metals to microbiome-driven immune dysfunction. Heavy metals such as Ni, Cd, and Pb can alter microbial composition, promoting dysbiosis that may amplify inflammatory and estrogenic responses. This mechanistic pathway strengthens the environmental theory by demonstrating how exposure to metal contaminants could result in microbiome-induced immune suppression, allowing endometrial lesions to thrive. 

Coelomic Metaplasia Theory The coelomic metaplasia theory posits that endometriotic lesions arise from the transformation of coelomic epithelium. However, it does not fully explain distant lesions in the lungs or brain. Microbial metallomics could address this by proposing that microbial metallophores enable pathogenic bacteria to survive and migrate systemically, seeding endometriotic tissue in ectopic locations. The involvement of microbial biofilms, which have been observed in endometriotic lesions, further supports the idea that microbes play a role in lesion survival and migration. 

Müllerianosis Theory Müllerian remnants provide a developmental basis for endometriosis, but this theory does not account for cases in males or locations outside the reproductive tract. Microbial metallomics suggests that certain microbes, adapted to metal-rich environments, can establish inflammatory niches in ectopic tissues. This means that endometrial-like lesions may develop as a consequence of immune dysregulation, metal accumulation, and microbial persistence in tissues that are not traditionally linked to Müllerian duct remnants.

Microbiome Theory The microbiome theory suggests that dysbiosis contributes to endometriosis, but it remains unclear whether dysbiosis is a cause or consequence of the disease. Microbial metallomics strengthens this theory by demonstrating that metalloestrogens and toxic metals actively select for dysbiotic microbes that enhance inflammatory responses and immune evasion. This suggests a bidirectional relationship in which heavy metals fuel microbial dysbiosis, which in turn exacerbates endometriosis progression. 

Genetic and Epigenetic Theory While genetics and epigenetics explain susceptibility to endometriosis, they do not fully account for environmental influences. Microbial metallomics provides a direct mechanism by which environmental metal exposure could induce epigenetic changes. Toxic metals are known to alter DNA methylation, histone modifications, and non-coding RNA expression, which could lead to immune dysregulation, increased estrogen sensitivity, and chronic inflammation—all hallmarks of endometriosis. 

Lymphovascular Metastasis Theory The lymphovascular metastasis theory suggests that endometrial cells spread via blood and lymphatic circulation but lacks consistent evidence of survival and implantation. Microbial metallomics offers an alternative explanation by proposing that metallophore-producing bacteria facilitate systemic dissemination of endometriotic lesions, allowing microbial biofilms to create microenvironments conducive to lesion survival in distant organs. This could explain why endometriosis has been detected in the lungs, brain, and even skeletal muscle—areas not easily explained by lymphatic spread alone. Conclusion Microbial metallomics provides a unifying framework that enhances existing endometriosis theories by incorporating the role of metal-microbe interactions. This theory helps to explain why only certain individuals with retrograde menstruation develop endometriosis, how environmental exposures influence the disease, and why lesions appear in distant or unexpected locations. By considering microbial metallomics as a key driver of immune dysregulation, estrogenic signaling, and lesion persistence, this model offers novel insights for diagnostics, prevention, and microbiome-targeted therapies in endometriosis treatment.

Discussion

The Microbial Metallomics Theory of Endometriosis offers a novel paradigm that connects heavy metal exposure, microbiome dysbiosis, and immune dysfunction as fundamental drivers of endometriosis pathogenesis. While previous research has explored individual contributors such as retrograde menstruation, genetic susceptibility, and hormonal imbalances, this theory integrates these elements within a broader environmental and microbiome-driven framework.

One of the primary strengths of this theory is its ability to address inconsistencies in existing models. For instance, while retrograde menstruation explains the deposition of endometrial cells in ectopic locations, it does not fully clarify why only some individuals develop endometriosis. By incorporating the role of metalloestrogens and microbial metallophores, this model suggests that metal-induced immune modulation and dysbiosis create a microenvironment that promotes lesion survival and immune evasion.

Moreover, the interaction between heavy metals and microbial virulence provides a compelling explanation for the heterogeneity of endometriosis presentations. Pathogens associated with the disease, such as Proteobacteria and Staphylococcus spp., may exploit metallophores to manipulate metal availability, thereby influencing inflammation, estrogen metabolism, and tissue invasion. This microbial metallomics perspective is critical because it highlights potential therapeutic targets, such as metal chelation therapy, microbiome modulation, and immunoregulatory interventions.

A significant implication of this theory is the need for interdisciplinary research that bridges gynecology, microbiome science, and metallomics. Future studies should investigate metal-microbe interactions within endometriotic lesions, assess metallophore-producing bacterial populations in affected individuals, and determine the efficacy of metal chelation therapies in alleviating symptoms. Additionally, metabolomic and transcriptomic studies could elucidate the precise molecular pathways by which metalloestrogens alter endometrial cellular behavior.

Despite its strengths, this theory requires further validation through clinical trials and mechanistic studies. While associations between heavy metal exposure and endometriosis risk have been established, more research is needed to confirm whether microbial metallomics directly drives lesion persistence and progression. Additionally, the impact of nickel sensitivity, cadmium exposure, and other environmental toxicants on endometrial and immune cell function should be explored in greater detail.

Conclusion

The Microbial Metallomics Theory of Endometriosis provides a groundbreaking synthesis of environmental toxicology, microbiome research, and immune-metabolic interactions in the pathogenesis of endometriosis. By proposing that heavy metals, microbial metallophores, and host immune responses drive disease progression, this theory expands current understanding beyond traditional models centered solely on hormonal dysregulation and immune dysfunction.

This perspective not only offers new insights into disease mechanisms but also opens novel therapeutic avenues. If validated, interventions targeting metal detoxification, microbiome modulation, and immune recalibration could revolutionize endometriosis treatment. Future research should prioritize clinical trials assessing the role of microbial metallomics, with a focus on identifying specific microbial signatures, metal-binding proteins, and therapeutic interventions that could mitigate disease severity.

Ultimately, this theory has the potential to reshape the clinical approach to endometriosis by shifting the focus from symptom management to targeting underlying environmental and microbial drivers. Continued interdisciplinary collaboration will be essential in translating these insights into effective diagnostics and precision medicine therapies, paving the way for a more comprehensive and effective management strategy for endometriosis.

The Microbial Metallomics Theory of Endometriosis offers a paradigm shift by integrating environmental toxicology, microbiome research, and host immune-metabolic interactions into a comprehensive disease model. By linking heavy metals, microbial metallophores, immune evasion, and epigenetic regulation, this theory provides novel insights into endometriosis pathogenesis. Future research should explore microbial metal interactions in the endometrial microenvironment to inform microbiome-targeted and metal detoxification therapies, offering new diagnostic and therapeutic avenues for managing endometriosis.

The Microbial Metallomics Theory of Endometriosis offers a paradigm shift by integrating environmental toxicology, microbiome research, and host immune-metabolic interactions into a comprehensive disease model. By linking heavy metals, microbial metallophores, immune evasion, and epigenetic regulation, this theory provides novel insights into endometriosis pathogenesis. Future research should explore microbial metal interactions in the endometrial microenvironment to inform microbiome-targeted and metal detoxification therapies, offering new diagnostic and therapeutic avenues for managing endometriosis.

References

1. Endometriosis: Epidemiology, Diagnosis and Clinical Management.. Parasar P, Ozcan P, Terry KL.. (Curr Obstet Gynecol Rep. 2017)
2. Brief Review of Endometriosis and the Role of Trace Elements.. Osuchowska-Grochowska, Ida & Blicharska, Eliza & Gogacz, Marek & Nogalska, Agata & Winkler, Izabela & Szopa, Agnieszka & Ekiert, Halina & Tymczyna-Borowicz, Barbara & Rahnama-Hezavah, Mansur & Grochowski, Cezary.. (International Journal of Molecular Sciences.)
3. Causal effects of gut microbiome on endometriosis: a two-sample mendelian randomization study.. Liu Z, Chen P, Luo L, Liu Q, Shi H, Yang X.. (BMC Womens Health. Nov. 30, 2023.)